CostGrade

Banner Estrella Medical Center vs Valleywise Health Medical Center

The same procedures, at each hospital, with what they charge and what that care is actually paid for.

C

Banner Estrella Medical Center

Phoenix, AZ

5.1x

charged per $1 actually paid

C

Valleywise Health Medical Center

Phoenix, AZ

2.9x

charged per $1 actually paid

CostGrade C C
Score out of 100 45 53
Rank in state #17 #11
Procedures priced 58 10
CMS quality stars 3/5 1/5
Ownership Voluntary non-profit - Private Government - Local

The same procedures, priced at each

Only procedures every hospital here publishes a price for, so the comparison is like for like.

Procedure Banner Estrella Medica... Valleywise Health Medi...
Comprehensive Observation Services $18,793 $24,853
Sepsis (severe) $73,628 $91,865
Level 2 Excision/ Biopsy/ Incision and Drainage $9,523 $8,540
Heart Failure (severe) $54,893 $41,065
Level 2 Upper GI Procedures $9,628 $8,174
Respiratory Failure $51,135 $50,953
Skin Infection (without major complications) $31,712 $36,292

Green marks the lower charge on that row.

Add another hospital

B

Flagstaff Medical Center

Flagstaff, AZ

3.1x — bills about $3.10 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

111 procedures priced CMS quality 4/5 Voluntary non-profit - Private
B

Mayo Clinic Hospital

Phoenix, AZ

3.5x — bills about $3.46 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

275 procedures priced CMS quality 5/5 Voluntary non-profit - Private
B

Tucson Medical Center

Tucson, AZ

3.9x — bills about $3.88 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

193 procedures priced CMS quality 2/5 Voluntary non-profit - Private