CostGrade

Methodist Hospitals Inc vs Parkview Noble Hospital

The same procedures, at each hospital, with what they charge and what that care is actually paid for.

D

Methodist Hospitals Inc

Gary, IN

5.8x

charged per $1 actually paid

A

Parkview Noble Hospital

Kendallville, IN

2.1x

charged per $1 actually paid

CostGrade D A
Score out of 100 29 80
Rank in state #59 #2
Procedures priced 78 10
CMS quality stars 1/5 3/5
Ownership Voluntary non-profit - Private Voluntary non-profit - Private

The same procedures, priced at each

Only procedures every hospital here publishes a price for, so the comparison is like for like.

Procedure Methodist Hospitals In... Parkview Noble Hospita...
Comprehensive Observation Services $21,318 $15,702
Sepsis (severe) $89,489 $30,860
Level 2 Excision/ Biopsy/ Incision and Drainage $11,512 $7,413
Heart Failure (severe) $38,600 $25,866
Respiratory Infection (severe) $59,178 $31,810
Pneumonia (severe) $49,888 $26,240
Level 1 Nerve Procedures $8,276 $7,556
Sepsis (without major complications) $44,437 $21,894
Respiratory Failure $50,244 $27,566
Kidney Failure (with complications) $37,663 $19,000

Green marks the lower charge on that row.

Add another hospital

B

Monroe Hospital

Bloomington, IN

2.8x — bills about $2.76 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

11 procedures priced CMS quality 4/5 Proprietary
B

Marion General Hospital

Marion, IN

2.9x — bills about $2.87 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

34 procedures priced CMS quality 3/5 Voluntary non-profit - Private
C

Parkview Whitley Hospital

Columbia City, IN

3.0x — bills about $3.02 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

15 procedures priced CMS quality 4/5 Voluntary non-profit - Private
B

Reid Health

Richmond, IN

3.3x — bills about $3.32 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

122 procedures priced CMS quality 2/5 Voluntary non-profit - Private
B

Memorial Hospital

Logansport, IN

3.5x — bills about $3.53 in charges for every $1 of care actually paid for

24 procedures priced CMS quality 4/5 Government - Local